Direct vs Indirect Cash Flow Forecasting: Which Method Works Best for Your Business?

Direct Cash Flow Forecasting Definition

Direct cash flow forecasting, sometimes known as the 'receipts and disbursement method,' predicts future cash inflows and outflows by collecting expected cash receipts and payments over short-term periods, usually weeks or months. Focusing on detailed operational data such as customer payments and vendor obligations creates more precise direct cash flow forecasts.

How to Build a Direct Cash Flow Forecast

Step 1: Gather data on expected cash inflows like customer payments, loan proceeds, and other impending revenue sources.

Step 2: Identify all anticipated cash outflows such as supplier payments, payroll expenses, rent, utilities, and other cash expenditures.

Step 3: Create a weekly or monthly timeline to organize and sort cash inflows and outflows, marking expected dates. 

Step 4: Compile the detailed transaction data for each period to map out the expected cash movements.

Step 5: Analyze the specific periods of cash surpluses and deficits by comparing the total cash inflows against the total cash outflows.

Step 6: Adjust the forecast for any predicted changes in operational activities, pricing, or external factors that can influence cash transactions.

Step 7: Regularly review and update the forecasted data to ensure it aligns with real-time business activities and market trends.

Indirect Cash Flow Forecasting Definition

Indirect cash flow forecasting uses historical financial statements to predict future cash flows. Examining the relationship between net income and changes in balance sheet accounts (e.g. accounts receivable and payables) provides an indirect view into cash inflows and outflows. Although less detailed than direct forecasting, this method captures the overall financial picture, while anticipating future cash needs.

For the indirect approach, you’ll likely use the following primary methods: 

• Adjusted Net Income (ANI): This method begins with net income and adjusts it for non-cash items, such as depreciation and amortization. By reconciling these figures, ANI provides a clear picture of actual cash generated by operations, helping businesses create more accurate projections.
• Pro Forma Balance Sheet (PBS): Here, you’ll use a forward-looking balance sheet to estimate future financial standing. By forecasting changes in assets and liabilities, PBS anticipates future cash flows and identifies potential liquidity challenges.
  
• Accrual Reversal Method (ARM): This approach reverses accruals to convert accrual-based net income into cash flow. Noting the timing differences between earning revenues and incurring expenses aligns projected net income with the expected cash position.

To sum it up, direct forecasting relies on real cash flow data, although it’s less reliable in the long run as you’ll eventually run out of data. Indirect forecasting uses projected financial statements, which are helpful in long-term planning.

How to Create an Indirect Cash Flow Forecast

Use the steps below to create an indirect cash flow forecast:

Step 1: Gather historical financial statements (e.g. historical income statements, balance sheets, and cash flow statements) going back at least 12-24 months. This information is the foundation of your forecast.

Step 2: Define the forecast period as monthly, quarterly, or annually, depending on your business's needs and the level of detail needed.

Step 3: Use your company's historical or projected income statement to Identify the net income figure for each period within your forecast period.

Step 4: Identify and adjust for non-cash items that affect net income but do not impact cash flow. 

Step 5: Analyze changes in working capital items (e.g. accounts receivable, accounts payable, and inventory) that can significantly affect cash flow. Calculate the change in each item for each period in your forecast. 

Step 6: Factor in capital expenditures (CapEx). These represent cash outflows for purchasing assets such as equipment, machinery, or property. Estimate when these expenditures will occur during your forecast period.

Step 7: Consider financing activities that affect cash flow, such as:

• Include any loans or credit facilities that provide cash inflow
• Principal repayments, which are cash outflows
• Capital raised through equity issuances

Step 8: For each period in your forecast, calculate the change in cash by adding or subtracting the adjustments in steps 4, 5, 6, and 7 from the net income figure (step 3). The result is the net cash provided by (or used in) operating activities.

Step 9: Start with the cash balance for the first period in your forecast and calculate the ending cash balance for each period by adding the change in cash (step 8) to the beginning cash balance of that period.

Step 10: Regularly update and review your cash flow forecast through the forecast period. Compare actual results to your forecast, and make adjustments to reflect changes in business conditions, assumptions, or strategies.

Before selecting a method, it helps to familiarize yourself with the advantages and disadvantages of each option.

Advantages of the Direct Method

Simplicity: Directly recording cash inflows and outflows allows for straightforward tracking and an understanding of cash positions. 

Immediacy: The direct method captures real-time cash movements, making it ideal for preparing daily and weekly reports for short-term decision-making. 

Accuracy:  Businesses can gauge their liquidity with a bottom-up approach, minimizing errors that can occur in more complex forecasting methods. 

Small Companies: Its simplicity and transparency help entrepreneurs without extensive financial backgrounds to effectively manage their finances. 

Disadvantages of the Direct Method

Resource intensive: The direct method requires  detailed tracking of every transaction t. This level of detail can be time-consuming, especially for businesses with a large volume of transactions.

Short-term only: This method is less effective for long-term forecasting. It focuses on upcoming transactions which might not provide a complete financial picture over an extended period.

Non-Cash Transactions Overlooked: By focusing solely on cash transactions, Direct ignores non-cash factors, which can lead to inaccurate forecasts for businesses with more complex accounting structures. 

Dependency on Historical Data: Past data isn't always a reliable predictor of future conditions, particularly in rapidly evolving industries. Historical data means relying on indirect forecasting, which may not be able to adapt to market shifts or unexpected changes. This can result in cash flow mismatches.

Advantages of the Indirect Method

Longer-term view: The indirect method shows a long-term view of a business's cash flow, which is ideal for strategic planning. By starting with net income and adjusting for non-cash transactions, it offers insights into the broader financial impacts and sustainability. 

Understanding non-cash impacts: Incorporating non-cash transactions like depreciation and amortization provides deeper insights into your financial health. 

Accounts for future transactions: Using both historical financial data and non-cash adjustments gives you a better understanding of cash flow patterns and makes it easier to predict future financial transactions.

Disadvantages of the Indirect Method

Complex: Indirect cash flow forecasting is complex and often requires a deep analysis of financial statements, at challenge for those unfamiliar with intricate accounting methods.

Reliant on assumptions: The indirect method relies on estimates and assumptions, which can lead to inaccuracies if these assumptions do not hold.

Time-consuming: This method can be time-consuming, especially for startups or small businesses lacking comprehensive financial information or resources.

Not suitable urgent decision-making: It may not pinpoint short-term cash flow fluctuations accurately and can hinder rapid decision-making in pressing situations.

‍
When to Use Direct vs Indirect Forecasting

Startups and Small Businesses: Direct forecasting can be beneficial for startups and small businesses that need immediate visibility into their cash flow. Since these companies often deal with short-term cash needs and have simpler financial situations, the direct method gives a clear picture of their actual cash inflows and outflows.

Manufacturing Companies: For industries like manufacturing—which has complex operational requirements and large volumes of transactions— indirect forecasting is more useful. This method helps businesses understand long-term financial health by analyzing comprehensive financial statements and adjusting for inventory, payables, and receivables.

Retail Chains: Large retail chains with predictable sales patterns might lean towards indirect forecasting. The ability to leverage historical data for accruals makes it easier to project future cash flows based on past trends rather than current transactions.

Project-Based Businesses: Companies engaged in project-based work, such as construction or consulting, can combine both methods. By using direct forecasting for specific projects and indirect methods for overall financial stability, they can effectively manage short-term project cash flow needs and long-term financial planning.

Real Estate: Companies with multiple entities that heavily rely on cash, including real estate, hotels and other similar industries will combine a mix of both direct and indirect forecasting. Direct forecasting helps with day-to-day and operational decisions, while indirect forecasting informs long-term strategy and investment planning.

Other Factors to Consider When Choosing a Cash Flow Forecasting Method

Beyond industry or your business’s size, you can also choose a method based on the following factors:

‍Your goals: Is your focus short-term precision or long-term strategy? If you need granular cash flow insights for day-to-day cash management, direct forecasting might be more advantageous. If you need a long-term financial strategy, indirect forecasting provides a high-level perspective.

The data you have: What quality and quantity of historical financial data can you access? Direct cash flow forecasting relies on real-time cash transaction data, which isn’t always readily available. If you lack direct cash flow data, indirect forecasting based on financial statements can be a solid alternative.

‍Consider your resources: Note your available resources for data management and financial modeling capabilities. Direct forecasting can be data-intensive and may require sophisticated cash management systems. Indirect forecasting isn’t as resource-intensive and doesn’t require as much data mining.

Define timelines: Define the timeframes and list short-term and long-term goals. Direct forecasting provides short-term precision, while indirect forecasting can shed insights useful for strategic long-term planning.

Which is Better: The Direct or Indirect Method?

Understanding direct and indirect cash flow forecasting methods is crucial for effective financial planning. Each method has distinct advantages and challenges, tailored to different business objectives. 

For more precise, day-to-day cash management, direct forecasting offers clarity and immediate results. If your aim is comprehensive financial reporting and strategic planning, opt for the indirect method. 

When choosing which method best aligns with your company’s financial goals, consider the size of your business, the level of detail you require, and the resources at your disposal. Evaluating these factors will help create a cash flow management strategy you can feel confident with.

Panax’s flexible AI and Automation based Forecasting

Panax understands that companies with lean finance teams and complex treasury needs want flexible, accurate forecasting. AI-driven categorization within the Panax platform means forecasts are more accurate, and you can compare forecasts to actuals for increased accuracy and reporting. 

Within the Panax platform you can choose weekly or monthly forecasting options, and combine forecasting for scenario planning. Panax allows you to create forecasts that automatically roll week/week or month/month based on updated actuals - allowing you to focus on gaining insights instead and making decisions instead of on data entry.

To get a personalized demo of Panax’s forecasting capabilities, sign up here.

‍